M6ELA-4.4

Comparing Two Authors' Accounts

Learn how to compare and contrast two different authors' accounts of the same real event, identifying what each author includes and leaves out.

What you'll do in this lesson

A voice-first session with the Crimsora tutor on Comparing Two Authors' Accounts, then targeted practice and FRQs — with the tutor adapting to where you get stuck.

Start Comparing Two Authors' Accounts free

What this lesson covers

When two people witness the same event, they often tell the story differently. One person might focus on action and drama, while another emphasizes details about people's feelings or the setting. Authors do the same thing with real events. In this lesson, you will learn to read two accounts of the same historical event or situation and notice what makes them similar and what makes them different — which details each author chose to tell, and which details they left out. This skill helps you understand that there are many ways to tell a true story, and comparing accounts gives you a fuller, more complete picture.

What Does It Mean to Compare Two Accounts?

When two authors write about the same real event, they are both telling the truth, but they are not telling the same story. An account is a written description or record of what happened. Comparing two accounts means reading both carefully and noticing what is the same and what is different. You might find that one author describes the event in more detail, while the other is shorter. One author might focus on one person's role, while another focuses on a different person. One account might include dialogue or direct quotes from people involved, and the other might summarize events without using exact words. The goal is not to decide which account is "right" and which is "wrong" — both can be accurate — but to notice what each author chose to show you and what each author chose not to mention. This helps you become a stronger reader and thinker.

Key Differences to Notice

When you read two accounts of the same event, look for these kinds of differences: First, check what details are included. Does one account mention names, dates, or specific places that the other leaves out? Second, notice the focus or emphasis. Is one account about what happened, while the other is about why it happened or how people felt? Third, look at the amount of information. One author might spend several paragraphs on one part of an event, while another author rushes through that same part. Fourth, pay attention to the evidence. Does one account use direct quotes from people involved, while the other only paraphrases or summarizes? Fifth, notice whether the authors describe events in the same order, or if one account rearranges the sequence. Finally, look for gaps — information that is in one account but completely missing from the other. A detail might seem small, but the fact that one author included it and another did not can change how you understand the event.

What Do Accounts Have in Common?

While accounts are different, they also have similarities. Both accounts should be about the same core event — the same basic facts of what happened, the same time period, and the same people or situation. Both should have some overlap in details or information, even if one account is longer or shorter. When you compare accounts, you are looking for those places where the authors agree or tell the same part of the story. Finding similarities helps you identify what both authors saw as the most important or most necessary information to include. If both accounts mention a specific date, person, or action, that is a clue that this detail matters. Similarities also help you check that both accounts are about the actual same event. If two accounts have nothing in common, they might be about different events altogether. By finding what the accounts share, you build a stronger foundation for understanding the differences.

Using a Chart to Organize Your Thinking

A helpful tool for comparing two accounts is a simple chart. Set up three columns with headers: Details in Account 1 Only, Details in Both Accounts, and Details in Account 2 Only. As you read, list the information from each author in the correct column. If both authors mention that an earthquake happened on a certain date, that goes in the middle column. If only one author describes the damage to buildings, that goes on one side. This visual organization helps you see at a glance what each author chose to include. It also makes it easier to spot patterns — for example, you might notice that Account 1 focuses on people and feelings while Account 2 focuses on dates and timelines. A chart also prepares you for the next step in close reading: understanding why an author might have made these choices. For now, your job is to notice and record the differences and similarities. The chart is your tool for doing that work clearly and accurately.

How to Read Accounts Carefully

To compare accounts well, read both texts all the way through at least once without stopping to make notes. This first read gives you a sense of each author's overall focus and what the account is about. Then read the first account again, more slowly, and write down all the details, events, and information the author includes. Do the same for the second account. Only after you have both texts clearly in mind should you start to compare them. Look at your notes or use a chart to match up information. Does this detail from Account 1 appear in Account 2 too? What does Account 1 mention that Account 2 does not? What does Account 2 mention that Account 1 does not? Ask yourself these questions as you work. Finally, step back and think about what you learned. Did comparing the two accounts give you information you would not have gotten from reading just one? That is exactly the point. Reading two accounts teaches you more than reading one account alone.

Key terms

Account.
A written description or record of an event, experience, or situation, usually based on facts and real events.
Compare.
To look at two or more things and describe how they are alike or similar.
Contrast.
To look at two or more things and describe how they are different.
Details.
Specific pieces of information, such as names, dates, descriptions, or examples, that an author includes in a text.
Gap.
A missing piece of information; something that is in one account but left out of another.
Focus or Emphasis.
The main idea or topic that an author spends the most time and energy explaining or describing.
Evidence.
Information, facts, quotes, or examples that an author uses to support or explain something in the text.
Paraphrase.
To restate information in your own words rather than using the exact words of the original source.

Worked example

Read these two accounts of the same historical event. Account 1 is from a history textbook. Account 2 is from a personal letter written by someone who was there. Then list what details are in both accounts, what is only in Account 1, and what is only in Account 2.

Account 1 (History Textbook): On March 15, 1952, a volcanic eruption occurred near the village of Kapaa on the island of Maui in Hawaii. The eruption lasted for three days and produced a lava flow that destroyed several homes. Scientists estimate that the lava flowed at a speed of one mile per hour. No one was seriously injured because residents had time to evacuate.

Account 2 (Personal Letter): Dear sister, I must tell you about the terrible mountain! On Tuesday we heard a loud rumbling sound early in the morning, and my neighbors and I gathered in the street. The mountain opened and poured out bright orange and red fire. I have never seen anything so frightening. We grabbed what we could carry and left immediately. My best friend's house was destroyed, but thankfully her family had fled to safety. We stayed with relatives in the next valley for three days until the fire stopped.
Step 1: Read both accounts all the way through to get the overall picture. Account 1 is factual and detailed with specific information. Account 2 is personal and emotional, written by someone who lived through it.

Step 2: Identify details in both accounts. Both mention the eruption lasted about three days. Both describe lava destroying homes. Both note that people evacuated safely. Both place the event on the island of Maui in Hawaii (Account 2 says "the mountain" but references the location through context).

Step 3: List details only in Account 1. The specific date (March 15, 1952), the village name (Kapaa), that the lava flowed at one mile per hour, and that scientists made this measurement. Account 1 provides factual, precise details.

Step 4: List details only in Account 2. The time of day (early morning), the loud rumbling sound people heard first, the description of the lava as "bright orange and red fire," the writer's personal fear, that she grabbed things to carry, that she stayed with relatives in the next valley. Account 2 provides sensory details and personal experience.

Step 5: Step back and reflect. Account 1 gives you when and where the eruption happened and how fast it moved. Account 2 tells you what it felt like and sounded like to be there. Together, they create a fuller picture. The textbook account is organized and precise; the letter is vivid and emotional. Both are true, but they show different sides of the same event.

Practice questions

Two authors write about the same school fire. Author A mentions the date, the time it started, how many fire trucks arrived, and whether anyone was hurt. Author B describes the smoke, the noise of the alarm, how scared students felt, and what they did to evacuate. Which statement best describes the difference in focus between these two accounts?
  1. Author A focuses on facts and details, while Author B focuses on personal experience and feelings.
  2. Author A is longer and more detailed than Author B.
  3. Author A is about a school and Author B is about a fire.
  4. Author B includes more factual information than Author A.

Answer: Author A focuses on facts and details, while Author B focuses on personal experience and feelings.

The key difference is what each author chose to emphasize. Author A lists measurable, factual details like dates and numbers. Author B describes sensory experiences and emotions. Both are accurate, but they show different sides of the event. This is not about length — we are told nothing about which account is longer. Both accounts might be about the same fire, but that is obvious and not the point of the comparison.
You read two accounts of a snowstorm. Account 1 states: 'The snowstorm hit the city on January 12 at 3 p.m. Schools were closed. Twelve inches of snow fell. The storm ended at midnight.' Account 2 states: 'Snow began falling during the afternoon. Everything turned white. People were stuck in traffic for hours trying to get home. The snow finally stopped late at night, and we were so grateful it was over.' What is one important detail that appears in Account 1 but not in Account 2?
  1. That people were stuck in traffic
  2. That snow fell during the afternoon
  3. The specific date and time the storm started
  4. That everything turned white

Answer: The specific date and time the storm started

Account 1 provides the exact date (January 12) and time (3 p.m.), while Account 2 only says 'during the afternoon.' Account 2 does mention traffic and the snow turning white, but both accounts talk about these things in different ways. The biggest gap is that Account 2 leaves out the specific clock time and exact date. This shows that the textbook-style account prioritizes precise factual information, while the personal narrative focuses more on the experience and feelings.
When comparing two accounts of the same real event, what is the most important reason to notice the gaps — the details one author includes but the other leaves out?
  1. To decide which account is wrong
  2. To complete your understanding by seeing what each author thought was important
  3. To prove that one author is a better writer
  4. To count how many details each account has

Answer: To complete your understanding by seeing what each author thought was important

Gaps are not there to judge which author is right or wrong — both can be accurate. Instead, the gaps show you what each author decided mattered most. One author may have thought dates and numbers were crucial, while another thought emotions and descriptions were crucial. By noticing these gaps, you learn more about the event than you would from reading just one account. You also start to see how different people view and value information differently. This is valuable thinking practice, not a way to grade the authors.

FAQ

Can both accounts be true if they say different things?
Yes. Both accounts can be completely true even if they include different details or emphasize different parts of the same event. Think of it like two photographs of the same scene taken from different angles — both show the real thing, but each one shows a different view. One account might be true and mention the date and location, while another true account focuses on people's emotions. Neither one is lying; they are just telling the truth from different perspectives.
What should I do if I find information in one account that contradicts information in the other account?
If one account says it was sunny and the other says it was rainy during the same event, that is a real contradiction and worth noting. However, most accounts of the same event include different information rather than contradicting information. For now, focus on noticing what each account includes and leaves out. If you spot a true contradiction, write it down and ask your teacher. As you read more critically later, you will learn how to evaluate which source might be more reliable.
Do I need to read long accounts, or can I compare short ones?
You can compare accounts of any length. A textbook paragraph and a one-page letter can be compared just as easily as two long articles. In fact, comparing a short account to a long one can teach you a lot — you will notice that the short account chose only the most essential details, while the long account added more description and explanation. Length is not what matters; what matters is that both accounts are about the same real event and that you read them carefully to notice similarities and differences.
How will this skill help me in other classes?
Comparing accounts is a skill you will use in history, science, and social studies. In history, you might compare how different sources describe the same historical event. In science, you might compare how two scientists describe the results of an experiment. The core skill — reading carefully, noticing what is included and what is left out, and thinking about what that means — applies everywhere. This is why teachers ask you to compare texts; it helps you become a thoughtful, careful reader in every subject.

Learn this with a teacher, not a page

The Crimsora tutor teaches Comparing Two Authors' Accounts live — explaining on a whiteboard, asking you questions, and adapting to where you get stuck.

Try a live session free